This Christmas tune is a pretty tough one to pull off properly, but Josh Groban is not half bad at it. My little brother insisted I consider Il Divo's version as well - the quartet definitely have pipes to pull this off, as does Groban. Both artists treat the song with respect - not showboating, just hitting the melody smoothly and sweetly, as it was intended (I have the same complaints when people embellish too much on the Star Spangled Banner). Il Divo does have the benefit of harmonic ability, which Groban of course lacks as a solo artist... but ultimately, both versions pass my rigorous critiquing. Enjoy, and Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, Joyful Festivus, and all that jazz!
No comments:
Post a Comment